The most famous slice of cake in Hollywood finally has two witnesses. Selena Gomez and Martin Short stopped by Jimmy Kimmel Live to promote the new season of Only Murders in the Building, and Kimmel made Short relive the night he cut into the Selena Gomez wedding cake at her wedding to Benny Blanco, Rolling Stone reported on 20 November 2026. Kimmel even showed the photo of the Selena Gomez wedding cake. Gomez’s verdict: “I love the teeth marks of the fork where he tried to save it.”
Selena Gomez wedding cake: Martin Short’s defence
Short opened with the line of a man who knows he is guilty. “First of all, it’s insane because I am blameless in the story,” he said, according to Rolling Stone. He described a “fabulous, beautiful wedding,” a main tent with 18 to 20 musicians, a dance floor and a nightclub, and lounge sections with sofas for groups of guests.
“And there was this cake there,” he said. “I just assumed it was a cake for each individual [group]. It turned out to be the wedding cake.” Short admitted to “maybe” having had a drink and said he dug in with a fork as Steve Martin was leaving the party. He even recalled turning to Paul Rudd afterwards to ask, “Should we just leave?”
Selena’s side: “I heard you ate my cake”
Here is the twist about the Selena Gomez wedding cake that fans did not know. Short, Gomez said, “apparently insisted” that nobody tell her. They patched the cake together. “I didn’t care,” she said. Then someone walked up and told her, “Marty cut your cake. And I think he was eating it.”
“So I run and he looks like a little dog with his tail between his legs,” Gomez said. “I go, ‘I heard you ate my cake.'” The cake, she explained, was meant as a private moment for her and Blanco. It became a moment for three. “We will always have that Selena Gomez wedding cake memory together and, honestly, I will never forget it.”
The wedding behind the story
Rolling Stone noted that Gomez and Blanco married last September after getting engaged in December 2024, and that Taylor Swift gave a speech at the celebration. Short and Martin attended along with other Only Murders cast members. Swift’s own week has been huge, as we covered in Taylor Swift returning to the CMA stage after 13 years.
Why this tiny scandal is golden for Only Murders
This is masterclass promotion. The new season of Only Murders in the Building is set in London and premieres on 8 December on Hulu, Rolling Stone said. A warm, funny, slightly naughty wedding story with a forensic photo of fork marks is exactly the kind of clip that travels. Gomez stays at the top of our Global Celebrity Brand Valuation index for a reason: she turns a private moment into public affection without giving away anything she does not want to.
Wedding stories are everywhere this week. Miley Cyrus and Maxx Morando are reportedly marrying this weekend, while Katy Perry and Justin Trudeau coupled up again at the Baby2Baby Gala. For seductive TV that lands this season, see Hollywood Movietimes on the Beast in Me Season 2 cast. And when a brand wants a star for a wedding, launch or gala, start with our 2026 Celebrity Booking Fees benchmark before you make the call.
Final ruling from this desk on the Selena Gomez wedding cake: Short is not blameless. But he gave Selena a story she will tell forever. Would you forgive him?
FAQ
What happened to Selena Gomez’s wedding cake?
Martin Short said he cut into it with a fork, thinking it was a cake for his group of guests, and it turned out to be the wedding cake, Rolling Stone reported.
How did Selena Gomez react?
She told Jimmy Kimmel she did not care, joked about the fork teeth marks, and said she will never forget the memory with Short and Benny Blanco.
When does Only Murders in the Building return?
Rolling Stone reported the new season, set in London, premieres on 8 December on Hulu.
