At the stroke of midnight, U2 put out their first album of new material in nine years. They saved the last word for Dolly Parton.
“Torn,” a duet between Parton and Bono, closes Carnaval De Luz, the Irish band’s 16th studio album, which arrived Friday on Island Records. Her official site and the band have been clear about what the track is: Parton’s final recorded vocal performance, cut in Nashville in June, two months before she died on 25 August at 80, after a brief battle with cancer.
The collaboration itself was not a last-minute surprise. When U2 announced the album, they already named “Torn” as the closing track and credited Parton on it. Friday is the first time anyone can actually hear the last studio performance she gave.
The session she got out of bed to finish
Parton recorded her vocals at Blackbird Studios in Nashville, according to her official site. The song was co-written by U2, Parton and Snow Patrol’s Johnny McDaid. Jacknife Lee produced the track, and Daniel Lanois added pedal steel.
Bono has already said the recording is hard for him to sit with. “When she got ill, she got out of her bed to sing this song,” he told Rolling Stone. “And you can hear that. And I can’t even listen to it now.” He was stunned by the performance itself. “She sang her heart out,” he told the magazine, “and I cannot believe that’s an 80-year-old woman.”
This was not a vault leftover finished without her. Billboard reports that Parton approved the final mix before her death. Producer Garret “Jacknife” Lee told Rolling Stone she “loved it,” adding, “She was so proud of her vocal and the recording.” Bono later described those sessions in sobering terms: “It’s very moving to have had these intimacies with such a figure. The fact that they’re not there now, in any way you can call back, other than through her songs, is very sobering.”
From a love triangle to a family at war
The song did not start as the one fans are hearing today. Bono first approached Parton about a still-in-progress Irish-roots side project and played her a few sketches over the phone. Her reply, he recalled to Rolling Stone, was, “That’s a little too Irish.” She later sent him a song of her own, titled “Torn.”
In Parton’s original draft, the magazine reports, the story followed a woman trying to choose between two men. Bono and McDaid rewrote the lyrics around a mother watching her family split apart. The finished song still opens as if it might be a love triangle, then widens in the chorus, with loving hearts that “beat and break the same” and a “house divided.” One line Variety highlighted puts the ache plainly: “Nothing hurts a mother more than a family at war.”
Bono has not been coy about the wider reading. “You name the location,” he told Rolling Stone, “but everyone knows what it is … People say in the U.S. now, people are scared to go into Thanksgiving.” Larry Mullen Jr. completed the recording with a drum part inspired by a Lanois production, Bob Dylan’s “Most of the Time.”
Island Records also issued additional versions of the country-tinged track, including the “Kent Wells Version” and a “T Bone Burnett Take,” all featuring Parton’s vocal. The Kent Wells cut, co-produced by Wells and represented by Big Machine Records, received an exclusive country radio world premiere on Thursday, a day before the album arrived.
Why it closes Carnaval De Luz
Carnaval De Luz — the title translates to “Carnival of Light” — is U2’s first collection of new material in nine years, and it arrives 50 years after Mullen pinned a handwritten notice to the message board at Mount Temple Comprehensive School in Dublin, looking for musicians to form a band. Billboard notes that a 24-track deluxe edition, followed by the surprise EPs Days of Ash and Easter Lily, is being presented as a double album, with “Torn” as the closing statement.
Bono has framed Parton’s entrance on the record as a crossing. “You sense a border crossing,” he said in a statement. “And so you move from the south into the north, and you have Dolly Parton singing to you as you cross the border.”
The Edge told Rolling Stone he hears in Parton something the band aspires to: “the radical center, which is becoming like a no-man’s-land right now.” In a polarized moment, he said, “she managed to get accepted by both sides and beloved by everyone. That’s an amazing thing. And she did it, as Bono pointed out today, with humor. Humor was her secret weapon.”
That gift is a large part of why this goodbye lands so heavily. Parton spent a lifetime being claimed by country radio, pop charts, Hollywood and just about every corner of the culture. Hearing her voice, recorded in June and released in November, is a reminder of how rare that kind of reach really is.
The tour that will have to carry the song
U2 are already preparing to take the album on the road. Billboard reports the band is working on plans for Carnaval De Luz presents: The Greatest Show On Earth World Tour, a live run in 2027. When the first dates were announced in October, we laid out the confirmed Latin American stadium nights, the presale windows and the album’s tracklist, including “Torn,” in our guide to the U2 Greatest Show On Earth Tour.
A song this loaded will be a delicate thing to play live. There is no second Parton vocal to recut, and no reunion left to tease. What remains is the recording she approved, the country version already in rotation, and a closing track that now has to stand as both a new U2 song and a last message from one of the most beloved voices of the last century.
