Actress Lisa Rinna has drawn attention to the ongoing Lindsay Clancy murder trial after publicly sharing a theory that contradicts the case presented in court. In a TikTok video posted Monday, Rinna said she believes Patrick Clancy, the father of the three children who died in January 2023, was responsible for their deaths rather than his former wife, Lindsay Clancy.
Rinna said she had discussed the case with her therapist and claimed that the two of them independently reached the same conclusion. She also cited her personal belief that women generally do not strangle people.
Her comments have generated discussion online, but it is important to distinguish Rinna’s speculation from evidence presented during the trial. There is currently no established court finding that Patrick Clancy killed his children, and Rinna has not presented evidence supporting her allegation.
Lindsay Clancy is facing three first-degree murder charges in connection with the deaths of her children. Her defense does not dispute that she caused the children’s deaths. Instead, her lawyers argue that she was suffering from severe mental illness, including postpartum psychosis, and therefore should not be held criminally responsible.
What did Lisa Rinna say about Patrick Clancy?
Rinna addressed the case in a video posted to TikTok, where she directly named Patrick Clancy and said she believed he was responsible.
“Alright he did it, Patrick did it,” Rinna said in the video. “Patrick’s the one who did it. Not Lindsay.”
She then explained that she had discussed the case with her therapist.
According to Rinna, her therapist also believed Patrick was responsible and told her, “He did it.”
Rinna said the conversation made her reconsider the circumstances surrounding the children’s deaths. She then argued that the manner of death did not fit her personal assumptions about how women would commit a violent crime.
“So awful to even say but that isn’t what a woman would do. They don’t strangle,” she said.
Rinna went further, suggesting that women who intended to kill someone would be more likely, in her opinion, to use methods such as poisoning or drowning.
Those comments represent Rinna’s personal theory rather than established facts in the case. There is no evidence presented in the material surrounding the trial that establishes Patrick Clancy killed the children.
Her statements have therefore become controversial because they introduce an accusation against a person who has not been established by the court as responsible for the children’s deaths.
What happened to Lindsay Clancy’s children?
The case centers on the deaths of Lindsay and Patrick Clancy’s three children: Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, who was eight months old.
The children died on January 24, 2023, at the family’s home in Duxbury, Massachusetts.
According to testimony surrounding the case, Patrick had left the house to pick up food and medicine. When he returned, he found Lindsay seriously injured outside the home after she had apparently jumped from a second-floor window.
He then went inside and discovered the children unresponsive in the basement.
The shocking discovery immediately led to a major investigation and eventually to murder charges against Lindsay.
Patrick later testified about what he found that afternoon. His testimony has also provided jurors with details about Lindsay’s mental health in the period leading up to the children’s deaths.
What has Patrick Clancy said about Lindsay’s mental health?
Patrick’s testimony has been a significant part of the trial because the defense is relying heavily on Lindsay’s mental state at the time of the killings.
According to testimony reported by news organizations, Patrick said Lindsay had experienced serious mental health difficulties during the months before the tragedy.
He described increasing anxiety and depression and said her condition became particularly concerning after she changed medication in December 2022.
Patrick testified that Lindsay lost weight, became severely depressed and began discussing suicide.
He also said Lindsay had told him about intrusive thoughts involving their children.
Those details are important to the defense because Lindsay’s lawyers argue that her actions were connected to severe psychiatric illness rather than a calculated decision to murder her children.
Patrick also testified that Lindsay had received professional treatment and had been admitted to psychiatric care before the killings.
At one point, however, he believed her condition was improving. He said she appeared better shortly before January 24, 2023, and he did not anticipate that anything so devastating would happen.
His testimony has presented a picture of a family dealing with an increasingly serious mental health crisis before the deaths.
What does Lindsay Clancy’s defense argue?
One of the most important aspects of the trial is that Lindsay’s defense is not primarily arguing that she did not cause the children’s deaths.
Instead, her lawyers are challenging whether she should be considered criminally responsible for what happened.
The defense has argued that Lindsay was suffering from postpartum psychosis and other serious mental health problems at the time.
Postpartum psychosis is a rare but severe psychiatric condition that can involve delusions, hallucinations, confusion and dramatic changes in behavior. In the most serious circumstances, it can be associated with a risk of harm to the individual or others.
The defense is seeking to convince jurors that Lindsay’s mental state prevented her from understanding the nature or consequences of her actions or from being legally responsible for them.
Prosecutors, however, dispute that interpretation.
The prosecution’s case centers on the argument that the killings were deliberate and that Lindsay should be held criminally accountable.
That disagreement over Lindsay’s mental state is at the heart of the trial.
Why has Lisa Rinna’s theory attracted attention?
Rinna’s comments have attracted attention partly because they introduce an alternative theory about a case that has already received significant public scrutiny.
Her claim that Patrick killed the children is dramatically different from the central arguments being made in court.
The defense is not claiming that Patrick killed the children. Instead, Lindsay’s lawyers acknowledge that Lindsay caused the deaths while arguing that her severe mental illness affected her criminal responsibility.
Rinna’s theory also relies heavily on a generalization about how women supposedly commit violent crimes.
That reasoning is not evidence. Criminal behavior cannot be reliably determined from gender-based assumptions about what someone would or would not do.
The circumstances of an individual case must instead be established through physical evidence, witness testimony, forensic findings and other information presented in court.
For that reason, Rinna’s comments should be understood as celebrity commentary and personal speculation, not as a development in the legal case.
What happens next in the Lindsay Clancy trial?
The trial remains focused on the evidence surrounding the children’s deaths and, critically, Lindsay Clancy’s mental state at the time.
Jurors are being asked to consider testimony about her behavior before and after the deaths, her psychiatric history, statements made to family members and medical professionals, and the circumstances surrounding the January 2023 incident.
The prosecution and defense have offered competing interpretations of the same period.
For prosecutors, the evidence is intended to demonstrate that Lindsay intentionally killed her children and should be held responsible under the law.
For the defense, the evidence is intended to demonstrate the devastating impact of severe mental illness and why Lindsay’s actions should be evaluated through that lens.
Patrick Clancy’s testimony is particularly significant because he was Lindsay’s husband and the father of the three children. His descriptions of her behavior before the tragedy could influence how jurors understand her mental state.
At the same time, his testimony does not establish the accusation made by Rinna.
Rinna’s comments remain separate from the courtroom evidence
The Lindsay Clancy case has become a subject of intense public interest, and Rinna is the latest public figure to offer an opinion.
However, there is a crucial difference between public speculation and evidence presented before a jury.
Rinna has accused Patrick Clancy of killing the children, but that allegation has not been established by the court. Her comments should therefore not be interpreted as proof of Patrick’s involvement.
The central legal question remains whether Lindsay Clancy is criminally responsible for the deaths of Cora, Dawson and Callan.
As the trial continues, jurors will ultimately have to weigh the evidence presented by both sides rather than outside theories circulating on social media.
Rinna’s remarks may generate headlines and online debate, but they do not change the charges against Lindsay or the evidence that prosecutors and defense attorneys are presenting in court.
For the families involved, the case remains a devastating tragedy involving three young children and a legal battle over one of the most difficult questions imaginable: how severe mental illness should affect criminal responsibility when a parent is accused of killing her own children.
