From a Senate floor attack in 1950 to a televised Virginia verdict in 2022, ten well-documented romances did more than fill tabloids. They moved Oscars, wrecked bookings, juiced openings, and rewrote how Hollywood prices a star after the scandal hits.
These ten controversial Hollywood relationships were reported at the time, argued in public, and, in the latest case, tested in court. Allegations stay labeled as allegations. Spouses and children dragged into the blast radius are not the punchline. For how private chaos still moves money, start with our Silicon Valley and Hollywood affairs file and our leaked-tapes feature on privacy lawsuits.
Ingrid Bergman and Roberto Rossellini
In 1949, Ingrid Bergman, then married to Petter Lindstrom, went to Italy to film Stromboli with married director Roberto Rossellini. Their affair became public, and she gave birth to their son, Roberto, in 1950, before her divorce was finalized. On 14 March 1950, Senator Edwin C. Johnson of Colorado attacked her on the Senate floor as “a powerful influence for evil.” Bergman stayed away from Hollywood filmmaking until Anastasia in 1956, which won her a second Oscar. In 1972, the New York Times reported, she received a public apology for that Senate attack.
Eddie Fisher, Debbie Reynolds, and Elizabeth Taylor
In March 1958, producer Mike Todd, Elizabeth Taylor’s husband and Eddie Fisher’s close friend, died in a plane crash. Fisher, then married to Debbie Reynolds, the pair billed as America’s sweethearts, comforted Taylor. A relationship followed and detonated in public. Reynolds, with two young children, became the sympathetic figure in the press. They divorced, and Fisher married Taylor in 1959, according to Reynolds’s interviews and the New York Times obituary of Fisher. His singing career never recovered its earlier sheen. Taylor’s stardom did not dip.
Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton
While filming Cleopatra, Elizabeth Taylor, still married to Fisher, and Richard Burton, then married to Sybil Williams, began a very public affair. A Vatican publication criticized Taylor, a rebuke the press shorthanded as “erotic vagrancy,” the Los Angeles Times later recalled. 20th Century Fox had sunk a record budget into the film, widely put at more than $40 million. Cleopatra still became the highest-grossing film of 1963 and later recouped, the New York Times reported in 1966. The affair made them a traveling box-office event.
Woody Allen and Soon-Yi Previn
In January 1992, Mia Farrow discovered nude photographs of her adopted daughter, Soon-Yi Previn, in Woody Allen’s apartment, as Vox later documented. Previn was about 21 and a college student. Allen, then 56, had been Farrow’s longtime partner, though they were never married and he was not Previn’s legal adoptive father. The family context is what shook the industry. They married in Venice in December 1997. The same year the photographs surfaced, a separate allegation of child sexual abuse was made. Allen has denied it, and no criminal charges were filed. The Guardian, citing a later biography, reported that Husbands and Wives, released in 1992, grossed about $10.5 million in the United States against a reported $25 million cost, and that Allen’s US audience shrank.
Meg Ryan and Russell Crowe
While filming the 2000 thriller Proof of Life, Meg Ryan, then married to Dennis Quaid, and Russell Crowe were widely reported to have had a brief affair. Ryan later said the marriage had already fallen apart and that Crowe was not to blame for its end. Proof of Life disappointed in the United States, and the BBC reported in 2001 that some people around the film felt the romance had damaged it. Newsweek later grouped that result with Kate and Leopold when it described studio doubts about Ryan’s bankability. The rom-com crown was gone.
Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie
Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie spent 2004 playing married assassins in Mr. and Mrs. Smith. Pitt was then married to Jennifer Aniston. Tabloids claimed an on-set romance. On 7 January 2005, Pitt and Aniston announced a separation after “much thoughtful consideration” and said it was not the product of tabloid speculation. In April 2005, photographs from Kenya made the new relationship public, Us Weekly and People later documented. Variety reported a $51.1 million domestic opening that June. The film grossed about $487 million worldwide on a $110 million budget, according to Box Office Mojo. Fox had worried the noise would hurt the movie. It juiced it.
LeAnn Rimes and Eddie Cibrian
In 2009, reports emerged that LeAnn Rimes and Eddie Cibrian had begun an affair while filming the Lifetime movie Northern Lights. Both were married, Rimes to Dean Sheremet and Cibrian to Brandi Glanville. The coverage was relentless, and Glanville later discussed the betrayal in public. The two marriages ended that year. Rimes and Cibrian married in April 2011 and have remained together. Rimes later told Rolling Stone how harsh the scrutiny had been and addressed the period on her 2013 album Spitfire. Country radio did not treat her as untouchable after that.
Kristen Stewart and Rupert Sanders
In July 2012, Us Weekly published photographs of Kristen Stewart, then dating Robert Pattinson, with Rupert Sanders, the married director of Snow White and the Huntsman. Stewart apologized for a “momentary indiscretion.” Sanders said he was “utterly distraught” over the pain caused to his wife and children, Reuters reported. The film had grossed about $397 million worldwide on a $170 million budget, Variety later noted. Sanders did not direct the follow-up, recast as The Huntsman: Winter’s War, and Stewart did not return as Snow White. She later told Variety she was not fired over the affair, though the Hollywood Reporter had earlier reported the studio was reconceiving the franchise without her.
Ben Affleck, Jennifer Garner, and the nanny reports
In 2015, Ben Affleck and Jennifer Garner announced the end of their ten-year marriage. Around that announcement, tabloids reported Affleck had been involved with the family’s former nanny, Christine Ouzounian. Affleck denied an affair and called the claims “complete garbage and full of lies,” People and TMZ reported. Those remain unproven reports, not findings. In a 2016 Vanity Fair interview, Garner said the nanny had nothing to do with their decision to divorce and that they had already been separated for months before she learned of the reports. Affleck kept working at the top of the studio system.
Johnny Depp and Amber Heard
Johnny Depp and Amber Heard married in 2015 and entered a highly public divorce in 2016, including a temporary restraining order obtained by Heard and a 2017 settlement in which Depp paid $7 million. In 2018, Heard wrote a Washington Post opinion essay about being a public figure representing domestic abuse, without naming Depp. In 2020, a UK judge dismissed Depp’s libel claim against The Sun over a “wife beater” headline, finding the paper had established a defense of substantial truth. After that judgment, Warner Bros asked him to resign from Fantastic Beasts, a departure he confirmed, the Hollywood Reporter detailed. In June 2022, a Virginia jury found Heard defamed Depp in the essay, awarding $10 million plus punitive damages later capped at $350,000, and found Depp, through a statement by his lawyer, defamed Heard on one of three counterclaims, awarding her $2 million. They settled the appeals in December 2022, the Associated Press reported, with Heard agreeing to pay $1 million, which Depp later directed to charities, CNN reported. Depp lost a franchise after the UK ruling and later began a public rebuild, including the Ebenezer opening tracked by Hollywood Movie Times. For how scandals now hit appearance contracts, see Celebrity Fees on why high-stakes personal scandals are rewriting 2027 appearance contracts.
That pattern also sits in our file on the end of a recent power couple. Across these ten controversial Hollywood relationships, the industry prices the damage, then prices the curiosity. Sometimes the curiosity pays for the picture. Sometimes a booking disappears.
FAQ
Which controversial Hollywood relationships most clearly changed a star’s career?
The ten cases in this file, from Ingrid Bergman and Roberto Rossellini to Johnny Depp and Amber Heard, all have a public record: contemporaneous reporting, official statements, or court outcomes. Bergman’s Hollywood exile and return, Allen’s narrower US market after 1992, Ryan’s lost rom-com crown, and Depp’s exit from Fantastic Beasts after the UK judgment are the clearest documented career shifts. Some scandals, including Mr. and Mrs. Smith, juiced the box office instead of sinking it.
Did the Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie reports help or hurt Mr. and Mrs. Smith at the box office?
Variety reported that the June 2005 opening, about $51 million domestically, was a career best for both stars, and Fox’s distribution chief said the media obsession did not hurt. The film went on to gross about $487 million worldwide, according to Box Office Mojo. Pitt and Jennifer Aniston had announced a separation in January 2005 and said it was not caused by tabloid speculation.
What did the courts actually decide in the Johnny Depp and Amber Heard cases?
In 2020, a UK judge dismissed Depp’s libel claim against The Sun, finding the paper had established a defense of substantial truth. In June 2022, a Virginia jury found Heard defamed Depp in a Washington Post essay and awarded him $10 million plus punitive damages later capped at $350,000, and also found Depp defamed Heard on one counterclaim, awarding her $2 million. They later settled the appeals, the Associated Press reported, with Heard agreeing to pay $1 million.
Do controversial Hollywood relationships still affect booking fees and studio deals?
Yes, when a studio or brand can point to a public record. Warner Bros asked Depp to leave Fantastic Beasts after the UK judgment, a departure he confirmed. Morality clauses and appearance-contract riders are now written with this risk in mind, which is why Celebrity Fees has been tracking how personal scandals are changing 2027 bookings. Curiosity can also raise an opening, as Mr. and Mrs. Smith showed.
